Surrogacy, Prostitution and Power

The body reveals the soul, so the body’s most intimate actions cannot be bought—this rules out the practice of surrogacy. The main problem with surrogacy is the separation of the unitive and procreative ends of the marital act, and as discussed previously, the commodification of children is a problem as well. But there are two further problems inherent to surrogacy. One is the buying and selling of a person’s body in ways that it cannot be bought, as with prostitution, and the other is the inherent power differential that can lead to abuse between…

More From Truth and Charity Forum
Sep, 29 2014

St. Francis de Sales, Saint of Courtesy and The Gentle Touch

Already as a university student in Padua, you made a rule for yourself never to avoid or curtail a conversation with anyone, no matter how unlikable and boring; to be modest and without insolence, free and without austerity, gentle without affectation, pliant and without…

Sep, 25 2014

When Utilitarianism Designs a Healthcare System…

By Denise Hunnell, M.D.

Ezekiel Emanuel, the architect of President Obama’s signature health care legislation, has penned a provocative piece published in The Atlantic and entitled Why I Hope to Die at 75. In this essay he argues that people over the age of 75 are a drain…

The Erosion of Marriage (National Catholic Register)
By Don DeMarco

Authentic Compassion Does not Include Assisted Suicide (Zenit)
By Denise Hunnell

Robin William’s Life of Comedy Ends in Tragedy (Aleteia)
By Caitlin Bootsma

The Moment of Choice: Recognizing Human Dignity in Difficult Circumstances (
By Fr. Shenan J. Boquet

Redeeming Eugenics? (Zenit)
By Dr. Denise Hunnell

The Papal Interview: A Survey of Reactions (Crisis Magazine)
By Joseph Meaney


Sep, 24 2014

Abandoned Babies Reveal Inherent Problems of Surrogacy

The budding practice of abandoning unborn babies with surrogates holds up a magnifying glass to the problems inherent in surrogacy: implanting embryos from a couple…

Sep, 22 2014

GAO Report Reveals Flagrant Violations of ACA Rules for Abortion Funding

On September 11, 2014, the Susan B. Anthony List finally prevailed in their four-year legal battle with former Ohio congressman, Steve Driehaus. The saga began…

Sep, 17 2014

A Divorce from Justice: Medical Standards of Abortion Clinics

“I don’t think that Judge Yeakel gets it” were the words Dr. Joe Pojman, executive director of Texas Alliance for Life, used to…

Sep, 23 2014

“Before You Said ‘I Do,’ What Did You Do? A New Report on Premarital Experiences & Marital Quality”

“Living in sin,” i.e. fornicating, i.e. living together, i.e. cohabitating. Our secular culture has a bad habit of changing the subject by…

Sep, 15 2014

Beyond the Headlines of Domestic Violence

The breaking graphic video of Ray Rice assaulting his then-fiancée sent a ripple of anger as the country became a bystander to the horrific…

Sep, 10 2014

False Expectations and the coming Synod

On September 1 of this year, the bishop of Antwerp, Belgium, Most Reverend Johan Bonny, produced a twenty-one page series of “wishes” concerning…

Sep, 19 2014

The Use and Abuse of the Mind

Everyone knows the meaning of fornication as a sin of the flesh, the immoral use of the body that commits the sin of lust…

Sep, 11 2014

Worlds Apart

I am a father and a philosopher. This is not necessarily an unusual combination, but it does give me a range of interests…

Sep, 2 2014

About The Nature of Things (De Rerum Natura)

The ancient philosophers sought to understand the order of the world by comprehending the nature of things. All things that exist have a nature…